By the letter of Your Fraternity you indicated that, after the letter to be sent to my predecessor, amid the delays of taking ship which the harshness of a prolonged winter was causing, our ordination had been announced to you by the favor of Almighty God, and that you rejoiced with brotherly affection because the Divinity had granted me the office of the pontificate. At this we were not surprised regarding your sincerity; for the affection of the discourse you sent presented you to us in such a way that, as I read over the letters of your love, I seemed to see you. Wherefore, embracing you with that same mind by which I saw you, I entreat the mercy of the Divinity, that in you the grace of restored tranquillity may bear fruit, and that Almighty God, who gave me the gift of the priesthood, may grant also the merit thereof.
Furthermore, to the matters which Gaius and Peter, our brothers and fellow bishops, and also Liberatus the deacon, our son, said had been enjoined upon them by Your Fraternity to treat with us by word of mouth, we have thought it fitting to give a reply by word, which, if it please the Lord, we do not delay to render through our legates. Moreover, restoring to Your Charity all the metropolitan rights which the perversity of enemies had seized, we exhort you that whatever we have written back in your name or that of others, you ought to make known to all; for, supported by the authority of a metropolitan, let no one plead in excuse that he is ignorant of what the primacy of the Apostolic See has prescribed by consideration of the canons. Given the fifth day before the Ides of September, after the consulship of Paulinus, a most illustrious man.
(88.) BISHOP AGAPITUS TO JUSTINIAN AUGUSTUS. Although from the first-fruits of my priesthood I was manifoldly bound to render thanks for the gifts of the divine goodness, yet, venerable emperor, having received through Heraclius the venerable presbyter, our son, the addresses of Your Serenity, which you have sent most full of the richness of eternal fruit, the joys of my prayers are doubled in the Lord, because, with the advances of your felicity united, by so glorious a purpose of mind you subject earthly kingdoms to yourselves in such a way that you may at the same time acquire the heavenly ones. Of which thing there are no doubtful proofs, since in your oracles which you have sent the light of the Catholic profession so shines forth that it may glitter even in blessed works.
For that is full and firm belief in our God which the richness of spiritual fruits at the same time commends, as the Vessel of Election declares, saying: In Christ Jesus neither circumcision avails anything nor uncircumcision, but faith which works through love. For what greater work of your faith could there be than that you have exalted the Apostolic See with such titles of charity and munificence that you have surpassed even the very desires of those who hoped?
And indeed this practice, as I too have proved, has always flourished in you of old through the grace of God: that the greatness of your quantity of resources might display the merit of your bounties, and that you might strive toward those advances of the power you had attained in such a way that the kindness inborn in you might either forestall or surpass the prayers of those who ask. Hence it is that your tranquillity glories in prosperous successes even up to the summit of the sovereign crown and now beyond it, and will never be defrauded of heavenly aids, because it is written: To those who love God all things work together for good.
Wherefore I too, together with the devotion of a Church giving thanks, as you commanded, have caused the most pious utterances of Your Liberality to be attached to the divine ministries, so that they may be brought before the gaze of the supernal Majesty with unwearied prayers ever, and that there may be an everlasting remembrance for obtaining your recompenses for you. And therefore, most clement lord and son, reverently discharging the homage of the most abundant salutation, I embrace you in the bosom of spiritual charity, hoping that, out of my devotion, so far as is in me, in those things which you command for the unity of ecclesiastical peace, you may rather promise to yourselves the things that are Catholic, according to that which the Apostle says:
so that what is in me is ready for you also; and do not believe that in any of those matters in which we may lawfully obey, we resist the exhortations of your gentleness—because, as the Teacher of the Nations asserted, I have hope that, as your faith increases, I shall be magnified in you according to our rule. And therefore I render boundless thanks to our God, that for the multiplication of the Catholic people you burn with so great an ardor of charity that, wherever your empire is extended, the everlasting kingdom soon begins to advance. Pressing more vehemently upon the zeal of this benevolence, we too, in acquiring those whom you signify wish to shun the Arian perfidy, judge that we can decline the censure of the paternal tradition, namely:
namely, that they should persevere even in those honors which they held among the heretics, and be promoted to others. Wherefore this is indeed good and eminently worthy of the highest praise—that you desire to gather all into the Lord's sheepfold through true faith; but it is not fitting for us to receive those who strive not to enter rightly, as the blessed Apostle Paul admonishes: Giving offense to no one, that our ministry be not blamed.
But how great an offense against the paternal constitutions would be incurred, if they were so received (which God forbid), lest anything should escape Your Piety, I have believed that the very rules should be appended, which specifically decreed that no one of such persons, once reconciled, should be advanced by the promotions of ecclesiastical rank, nor should desire to possess honors any longer—honors which he ought no longer to doubt that he has culpably acquired. From these Your Piety will be the better able to estimate whether it is in any way permitted to violate the so open and synodal statutes of the Apostolic See, when the sentence of the Apostle cries out: If, however, I build again the same things which I destroyed, I make myself a transgressor.
And therefore, secure, I profess with the very voice of the Apostle that I trust in you and in the Lord that you think nothing otherwise; for indeed, as the same Teacher asserted, I too am certain concerning you, that you are full of goodness, filled with all knowledge, so that you are able to admonish one another. If therefore these of whom you have informed us hasten to come to the right faith, let them not refuse to follow the rules of our faith, since the Lord says: If anyone wishes to come after me, let him deny himself and follow me. But if they are still stirred by the blameworthy ambitions of honor, and for the gain of the holy faith dread to suffer the losses of human glory, they themselves declare that they have not yet departed from vices and error, and that they wish rather to entangle us in their own excesses.
Concerning such persons therefore the Apostle says: They are zealous for you, but not rightly; rather they wish to exclude you, that you may be zealous for them. Since this is so, believe that by this nothing is diminished from your holy zeal, by which you desire the Catholic Church to be enlarged, if such men are not received into the clergy—the Apostle forewarning: For what? If some of them have not believed, has their unbelief made void the faith of God? God forbid! For although by a like zeal of charity for the multiplication of the faithful that blessed Peter, the doorkeeper of the heavenly kingdom, was drawn—who, that he might win over more of the Jews, had descended from the doctrine and the regular path in not rejecting all Judaism—yet that younger Paul, a prisoner in the Lord, related that he had withstood him, saying:
But when I saw that they were not walking uprightly according to the truth of the Gospel, I said to Peter before them all: 'If you, being a Jew, live in the manner of the Gentiles, how do you compel the Gentiles to judaize?' Weighing these things therefore in all respects, with God seated in your heart, you will be able to recognize that we do not seek an occasion of excuse, but humbly make known to you those things which by reason of our office we cannot overstep, since the Apostle says: For we can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth. Whence also, concerning the person and cause alike of Bishop Stephen, do not believe that we are impelled by any zeal of defense (far be it from the minds of any Christians that
that in any person whatsoever they should either impugn innocence or absolve a crime); but all the things which have been ordained by the Apostolic See regarding this matter have ever flowed from that same zeal by which you too desire that in all things reservation be made to the primacy of blessed Peter—namely, that in the case of those who had sought the hearing of his See, the sentence of another should not come forth, in contempt of the reverence due to it. And therefore, since Your Clemency has salubriously deigned to offer that the whole affair be re-examined by our legates, we commit this task, God being author, to those whom we send without delay to the continent; yet in such a way that even now the religious man Achilles ought, by your command, to rejoice in our communion;
but in truth concerning his enjoyment of the priesthood, when all the things which our legates shall have learned are brought to us by their fullest report, the rules of the holy canons—which you command to be observed—having been considered, what is to be followed will be more firmly decreed.
But whereas Your Clemency has deigned to excuse the person of our brother and fellow bishop Epiphanius, because in the consecration of the aforesaid Achilles it was rather your command than his ordination that had come about, we believe that he too has recognized that he was rightly blamed; for, apart from the other things which he neglected, this at least he will scarcely be able to excuse—that to so most pious and most clement a prince, who defends also the privileges of blessed Peter, he did not, whether opportunely or importunely, suggest what in this matter was owed to the reverence of the Apostolic See. Concerning which affair, and also concerning the city of Justiniana, conscious of your glorious birth, and likewise concerning the vicariate to be enjoined of our See
—what, with the primacy of blessed Peter, whom you love, preserved, and with the affection of your piety, may be more fully deliberated, we make known speedily, God being favorable, through those legates whom we send to you. It remains that, as we unceasingly beseech blessed Peter, we may ever rejoice over the safety and prosperity of your empire. Given on the Ides of October. (89.) A COPY OF THE PETITION OF OUR MOST PIOUS LORD JUSTINIAN THE EMPEROR, WHICH HE GAVE TO POPE AGAPITUS AT CONSTANTINOPLE, CONCERNING THE FAITH.
IN THE NAME OF THE LORD OUR GOD JESUS CHRIST, THE EMPEROR CAESAR FLAVIUS JUSTINIANUS, ALAMANNICUS, GOTHICUS, FRANCICUS, GERMANICUS, ANTICUS, ALANICUS, VANDALICUS, AFRICANUS, PIOUS, FORTUNATE, RENOWNED, VICTOR AND TRIUMPHANT, EVER AUGUSTUS, TO AGAPITUS, MOST HOLY AND MOST BLESSED ARCHBISHOP OF THE FOSTERING CITY OF ROME AND PATRIARCH. The first safety is to keep the rule of the right faith and in no way to deviate from the tradition of the Fathers, because there cannot be passed over the sentence of our Lord Jesus Christ, who says: You are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church. These things which have been said are proved by the effects of events, because in the Apostolic See the Catholic religion is ever kept inviolable.
Desiring therefore not to fall from this faith, and following in all things the ordinances of the Fathers—that is, of the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers who were assembled at Nicaea and set forth the holy creed or symbol of the faith; and of the one hundred and fifty holy Fathers who convened in the city of Constantinople and elucidated and made manifest that same holy creed; and of the holy Fathers who were assembled at Ephesus in the first synod; and of the holy Fathers who convened at Chalcedon—and following the dogmas concerning the faith which are contained in each one of these, through which every heresy assailing the holy and Apostolic Church is removed; and approving in all things and embracing all the letters of Leo of blessed memory which he composed concerning the Christian faith; and confessing one and the same Christ, the Lord, the only-begotten Son, to be acknowledged in two natures—that is, in divinity and in humanity—without confusion, without change, inseparably; nowhere
the difference of the natures being taken away on account of the union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring into one person and subsistence; not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same only-begotten Son, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ, as the prophets of old taught concerning him, and Jesus Christ himself instructed us, and the symbol of the holy Fathers has handed down to us. We anathematize every heretic who, contrary to these things which have been said, has thought and thinks—especially Nestorius the heretic, formerly bishop of the city of Constantinople, condemned in the synod of Ephesus by Celestine of blessed memory, pope of the city of Rome, and by holy Cyril, prelate of the city of Alexandria;
and together with him we anathematize Eutyches and Dioscorus, formerly bishop of the city of Alexandria, condemned in the holy synod of Chalcedon, which we embrace and follow; joining to these Timothy the parricide, surnamed Aelurus, and his disciple and follower in all things, Peter of Alexandria, whom we likewise condemn. We turn away also from Acacius, formerly bishop of the city of Constantinople, a co-heretic and follower of what these had done, and likewise those persevering in their communion and participation; for whosoever embraces the communion of any persons, follows also a like sentence with them in their condemnation. In like manner we condemn also Peter of Antioch, together with his followers and all those written above.
quapropter, sicutpraefatisumus, sequentesinomnibussedemapostolicam, quaeabeastatutasunt, praedicamusetprofitemuristainconcusseseruarietcompellere, utiuxtatenoremlibelliistiusomnesfaciantepiscopi, utsanctissimiquidempatriarchaeaduestramfaciantsanctitatem, metropolitaniueropatriarchisetaliiutsuisfaciantmetropolitanis, quatenusperomniasanctacatholicanostraecclesiasuamhabeatfirmitatem. ETALIAMANU: Diuinitasteseruetpermultosannos, sancteacreligiosissimepater. Dat. XVII. KalendarumApriliumConstantinopolip. c. Belisariu. c. (90.) EXEMPLARLIBELLIMENAEPRESBVTERIETXENODOCIQVIPACTUSESTEPISCOPUSCONSTANTLVOPOLITANTSSUBDIEIII. ID.
Wherefore, as we have said before, following in all things the Apostolic See, we proclaim and profess the things which have been established by it to be observed unshaken, and we compel that, according to the tenor of this petition, all the bishops should so do—that the most holy patriarchs indeed should so do toward Your Holiness, but the metropolitans toward the patriarchs, and the others toward their metropolitans, so that in all things our holy Catholic Church may have its firmness. AND IN ANOTHER HAND: May the Divinity preserve you through many years, holy and most religious father. Given the seventeenth day before the Kalends of April at Constantinople, after the consulship of Belisarius, a most illustrious man. (90.) A COPY OF THE PETITION OF MENAS, PRESBYTER AND WARDEN OF THE HOSPICE, WHO WAS APPOINTED BISHOP OF CONSTANTINOPLE, ON THE THIRD DAY BEFORE THE IDES
MARTIASITERUMPOSTCONSULATUMPAULINIU. C. IUNIORIS. Primasalusestrectaefideiregulamcustodireetapatrumtraditionenullatenusdeuiare, quianonpotestdomininostriIesuChristipraetermittisententiadicentis: tuesPetrusetsuperhancpetramaedificaboecclesiammeam. haec, quaedictasunt, rerumprobantureffectibus, quiainsedeapostolicainuiolabilissempercatholicacustoditurreligio.
OF MARCH, AGAIN AFTER THE CONSULSHIP OF PAULINUS THE YOUNGER, A MOST ILLUSTRIOUS MAN. The first safety is to keep the rule of the right faith and in no way to deviate from the tradition of the Fathers, because there cannot be passed over the sentence of our Lord Jesus Christ, who says: You are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church. These things which have been said are proved by the effects of events, because in the Apostolic See the Catholic religion is ever kept inviolable.
Desiring therefore not to fall from this faith, and following in all things the ordinances of the Fathers—that is, of the three hundred and eighteen holy Fathers who were assembled at Nicaea and set forth the holy creed or symbol of the faith; and of the one hundred and fifty holy Fathers who convened in the city of Constantinople and elucidated and made manifest that same holy creed; and of the holy Fathers who were assembled at Ephesus in the first synod; and of the holy Fathers who convened at Chalcedon—and following the dogmas concerning the faith which are contained in each one of these, through which every heresy assailing the holy and Apostolic Church is removed; and approving in all things and embracing the letters of blessed
Leo of memory, all which he composed concerning the Christian faith; and confessing one and the same Christ, the Lord, the only-begotten Son, to be acknowledged in two natures—that is, in divinity and in humanity—without confusion, without change, inseparably; nowhere the difference of the natures being taken away on account of the union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring into one person and subsistence; not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same only-begotten Son, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ, as the prophets of old taught concerning him, and Jesus Christ himself instructed us, and the symbol of the holy Fathers has handed down to us:
We anathematize every heretic who, contrary to these things which have been said, has thought and thinks—especially Nestorius the heretic, formerly bishop of the city of Constantinople, condemned in the synod of Ephesus by Celestine of blessed memory, pope of the city of Rome, and by holy Cyril, prelate of the city of Alexandria; and together with him we anathematize Eutyches and Dioscorus, formerly bishop of the city of Alexandria, condemned in the holy synod of Chalcedon, which we embrace and follow; joining to these Timothy the parricide, surnamed Aelurus, and his disciple and follower in all things, Peter of Alexandria, whom we likewise condemn.
We turn away also from Acacius, formerly bishop of the city of Constantinople, a co-heretic and follower of what these had done, and likewise those persevering in their communion and participation; for whosoever embraces the communion of any persons, follows also a like sentence with them in their condemnation. In like manner we condemn also Peter of Antioch, together with his followers and all those written above. Wherefore, as we have said before, following in all things the Apostolic See, we proclaim the things which have been established by it. AND IN ANOTHER HAND:
I, Menas, by the mercy of God presbyter and warden of the hospice, accept the aforesaid holy four synods and all the dogmas which are contained in them, and the letters of Pope Leo which he composed for the faith; and I confess Christ our God to be acknowledged in two natures—that is, in divinity and in humanity—without confusion, without division; and anathematizing all who think otherwise, together with all who have been condemned, as has been said above. I have subscribed. (91.) BISHOP AGAPITUS TO JUSTINIAN AUGUSTUS.
We rejoice, venerable emperor, that you are kindled with so great an ardor for the Catholic faith that in all the seasons of your most pious life you clemently bring pious solicitude to preserving and increasing the concord of the churches, and desire that one faith, consimilar in all things by its own firmness, be preached to all Christian peoples. Nor is it any wonder that Your Clemency persists in such a thought pleasing to God, since there is no more blessed advancement of your empire than the increase of religion. Wherefore I will gladly sing this too even with the prophetic voice: Our mouth is filled with joy and our tongue with exultation, because we behold your most flourishing sovereignty daily adorned with divine benefits.
For you desire, venerable emperor, that we confirm also by our authority the letter of your piety concerning the exposition of your faith, recently sent to our predecessor of blessed memory, John, prelate of the Roman See, through the bishops Hypatius and Demetrius, and strengthened by the aforesaid prelate: we praise it, we embrace it—not because we admit to laymen the authority of preaching, but because we confirm and strengthen the zeal of your faith, which is in agreement with the rules of our Fathers; through which already both the unity of the Church comes about, and we trust that the remaining members of the Catholic Church will return to its structure by the constancy of your Christianity.
Appending below the tenor of which profession, or of your letter, we confirm by our authority the zeal which you wholly maintain toward God, proclaiming that a faith of this kind agrees with all the rules of our Fathers and accords with the dogmas of the Apostolic See; establishing that, if anyone shall attempt to contravene our Catholic faith—which, as consonant with the paternal rules for removing the suspicion of heretics, we confirm by the present definition—he shall be made a stranger to holy communion.
Whence also Cyrus and his followers, already before this suspended from the communion of the Catholic Church for this madness, and hitherto persevering in their perfidy, unless under canonical satisfaction they shall have attained the apostolic doctrine, we by no means suffer them to be restored to the sacred communion, but even subject them as heretics to the anathema; for we judge it worthy that whoever has despised to obey our constitutions should not defile the ecclesiastical estate and its purity. And the text of the letter is this: IN THE NAME OF OUR LORD JESUS CHRIST GOD, THE EMPEROR CAESAR FLAVIUS
JUSTINIANUS, ALAMANNICUS, GOTHICUS, FRANCICUS, GERMANICUS, ANTICUS, ALANICUS, VANDALICUS, AFRICANUS, PIOUS, FORTUNATE, RENOWNED, VICTOR AND TRIUMPHANT, EVER AUGUSTUS, TO AGAPITUS, MOST HOLY AND MOST BLESSED ARCHBISHOP OF THE FOSTERING CITY OF ROME AND PATRIARCH. Some time ago in this royal city of ours there arose, on account of certain men, a diseased contention concerning the faith, which, fittingly rejecting, we repressed by an edict interposed. And because it is our zeal to refer such emerging cases to the judgment of your Apostolic See, we have directed, by a legation sent through the venerable bishops Hypatius and Demetrius, the tenor of that same faith—which we have deemed to be followed—inserted into our letter, to your predecessor of blessed memory, John;
This letter, on behalf of the integrity of the faith, your aforementioned predecessor received with willing congratulation and confirmed with his own assent and that of the whole Roman Church. The text of this letter of ours runs as follows: 'Victor Justinian, Pious, Fortunate, Renowned, Triumphant, Ever Augustus, to John, most holy Archbishop of the nurturing city of Rome and Patriarch.'
Rendering honour to the Apostolic See and to your Holiness, as has ever been and is our desire, and honouring your Beatitude as befits a father, we hasten to bring to the notice of your Holiness all things that pertain to the state of the churches; for it has ever been our great endeavour that the unity of your Apostolic See and the state of the holy churches of God be preserved, which unity hitherto abides and continues undisturbed, with no contrary thing intervening. Therefore we have made haste to subject and to unite all the priests of the whole eastern region to the See of your Holiness.
And so, concerning the matters that have here been stirred up at present—although they are manifest and beyond doubt, and have always been firmly kept and proclaimed by all priests according to the teaching of your Apostolic See—we have judged it necessary that they should come to the notice of your Holiness. For we do not suffer anything that pertains to the state of the churches, however manifest and undoubted it be, to be set in motion without its also being made known to your Holiness, since it is the head of all the holy churches. For in all things, as has been said, we make haste that the honour and authority of your See may increase.
We therefore make manifest to your Holiness that a certain few, unfaithful men and strangers to the holy catholic and apostolic Church of God, have dared in Jewish fashion to contradict those things which by all the priests, according to your teaching, are rightly held and glorified and proclaimed; denying that our Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God and our God, incarnate of the Holy Spirit and of the holy and glorious Virgin and Mother of God Mary, made man and crucified, is one of the holy and consubstantial Trinity, to be adored and glorified together with the Father and the Holy Spirit, consubstantial with the Father according to his divinity and consubstantial with us, the same one, according to his humanity, capable of suffering in the flesh, yet the same one impassible in his deity.
For in refusing to confess that our Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God and our God, is one of the holy and consubstantial Trinity, they appear to be following the evil teaching of Nestorius, calling him Son of God according to grace, and saying that God the Word is one and Christ is another.
But all the priests of the holy catholic and apostolic Church and the most reverend archimandrites of the sacred monasteries, following your Holiness and keeping the state and unity of the holy churches of God which they have with the apostolic See of your Holiness, altering nothing whatever of the ecclesiastical state which hitherto has held and holds, with one consent confess and glorify, proclaiming that our Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son and Word of God and our God, begotten of the Father before the ages and outside time, in these last days came down from heaven and was incarnate of the Holy Spirit and of the holy and glorious Virgin and Mother of God Mary, born and made man and crucified, is one of the holy and consubstantial Trinity, to be adored and glorified together with the Father and the Holy Spirit.
For we do not acknowledge God the Word as one and Christ as another, but one and the same, consubstantial with the Father according to his divinity and consubstantial with us, the very same, according to his humanity, capable of suffering in the flesh, yet the very same impassible in his deity. For as he is perfect in his divinity, so the same one is likewise perfect in his humanity; for in one subsistence we receive and confess the union—which the Greeks call 'we confess the union according to hypostasis.'
And since the only-begotten Son and Word of God, begotten of the Father before the ages and outside time, the very same also in these last days coming down from heaven, incarnate of the Holy Spirit and of the holy and glorious Virgin and Mother of God Mary and made man, our Lord Jesus Christ, is properly and truly God, therefore we also call the holy and glorious Virgin Mary properly and truly the Mother of God: not because God the Word took the beginning of his being from her, but because in these last days he came down from heaven and, incarnate of her and made man, was born. Whom we confess and believe, as has been said.