CHAPTER I. Sorrowing, I have read your sorrowful letters, and with due grief I have run through your mournful writings; because, just as the peace of the Churches, the concord of the priests, the tranquility of the people, makes us rejoice with heavenly joy, so fraternal dissension afflicts and dejects us, especially when it arises from such causes. For thirty years human laws take away human questions, and the generation of Christ, which by divine law is written to be unspeakable (Isa. LIII, 8), after so many ages is bandied about by rash disputation. What Origen, the scrutinizer of first principles, incurred, how Nestorius fell disputing about the natures, is not hidden from your prudence. The Magi confess Jesus in the cradle to be God with mystic gifts (Matt. II);
and do priests, with lamentable questioning, inquire who He is who was born of a virginal birth by the Holy Spirit? When Jesus gave His infant cry in the cradle, the heavenly host cried out, 'Glory to God in the highest' (Luke II, 14); and now, when at the name of Jesus every knee bows, of things heavenly, earthly, and infernal (Phil. II, 10), is a question about His origin stirred up? We, brother, say with the Apostle: 'Even though we have known Jesus according to the flesh, yet now we know Him so no more' (II Cor. V, 16). Nor can we injuriously repeat the question, we who are commanded to give honor, and to render fear, and to await, not to dispute, Him whom we confess to be Judge. CHAPTER II.
This is the brief reply I have made, brother, to your letter, intending to write more fully if our brother and fellow-bishop Flavian had sent me anything in writing about this matter. For if it displeases you that you wrote of a judgment already given, how shall we be able to pass judgment upon those whom we do not even see because of their absence, and whose thoughts we do not know because of their silence? He is no just mediator who so hears the one party as to leave nothing in reserve for the other party. In all things, however, we exhort you, honorable brother, to give obedient heed to what has been written by the most blessed pope of the city of Rome; for blessed Peter, who both lives and presides in his own see, supplies the truth of the faith to those who seek it.
For we, out of zeal for peace and faith, cannot judge causes of faith apart from the consent of the bishop of the city of Rome. May the Lord deign to preserve your love in safety for a very long time, most dear and most honored son.