Chapter 38, verse 1.—'Then the Lord, answering Job out of the whirlwind, said.' I. In how many and what ways God speaks to men. I see that it must be noted that, if the speech were said to have been made to a sound and unharmed man, it would in no way have been written that the Lord spoke out of the whirlwind. But because He speaks to one who has been scourged, He is described as having spoken out of the whirlwind. For the Lord speaks to His servants in one way when He advances them inwardly through compunction, and in another when He presses them down through severity, lest they be exalted. For through the gentle speech of the Lord His lovable sweetness is shown; but through the terrible, His fearful power is displayed. In the former the soul is persuaded to make progress; in the latter, that which is making progress is restrained.
In the former he learns what to desire; in the latter, what to fear. Through the former He says: 'Rejoice and be glad, O daughter of Zion, for behold, I come, and I will dwell in the midst of you' (Zech. 2:10); through the latter it is said: 'The Lord will come in a tempest, and his ways are in the whirlwind' (Isa. 66:15). Gentle indeed is He who comes that He may dwell in the midst; but when He makes Himself known through tempest and whirlwind, He doubtless disturbs the hearts that He touches, and He exerts Himself to tame pride when He becomes known as powerful and terrible. Either through angels God speaks, or through Himself. It must moreover be known that divine speech is distinguished in two ways. For either the Lord speaks through Himself, or His words are formed to us through an angelic creature.
But when He speaks through Himself, He is opened to us by the sole power of inward inspiration. When He speaks through Himself, the heart is taught of His word without words and syllables, because His power is known by a certain inmost lifting up. To this the mind, when full, is suspended; when empty, it is weighed down. For it is a certain weight that lifts up every soul which it fills. It is an incorporeal light which both fills the interior and, when it has filled it, circumscribes the exterior. It is a speech without noise, which both opens the hearing and knows not how to have sound. For what is written of the coming of the Holy Spirit: 'Suddenly there came a sound from heaven, as of a rushing mighty wind, and it filled the whole house where they were sitting;'
'and there appeared to them divided tongues as of fire, and it sat upon each one of them' (Acts 2:2)—through fire indeed the Lord appeared, but through Himself He made the speech inwardly. And neither was the fire God, nor was that sound; but through what He displayed outwardly, He expressed what He wrought inwardly. For because He rendered the disciples both kindled with zeal and instructed with the word within, He showed fiery tongues without. In signification, then, the elements were brought near, so that their bodies might perceive fire and sound, but their hearts might be taught by the invisible fire and by a voice without sound. Outwardly, therefore, was the fire that appeared, but inwardly was that which gave knowledge.
And when the eunuch of Queen Candace, sitting in his chariot, was making his journey, and, not understanding, held Isaiah in his hands, the Spirit had said to Philip in his heart: 'Join yourself to this chariot' (Acts 8:29). And when Cornelius had sent soldiers who feared God to summon Peter, Peter without doubt heard in his mind from the Spirit: 'Behold, three men seek you; arise therefore, go down, and go with them' (Acts 10:19). For the Spirit of God, as it were, to speak certain words to us is to intimate by a hidden power those things which are to be done, and to render the ignorant heart of man suddenly expert concerning hidden things, without any noise and slowness of speech.
For because hearing does not grasp all at once the things that are spoken to it—since it perceives both the meanings through words, and the words piecemeal through syllables—but our sight, in that toward which it directs itself, apprehends the whole suddenly and at once; the speech of God made to us inwardly is seen rather than heard, because, while it intimates itself without delay of speech, with sudden light it illumines the darkness of our ignorance. Whence also Baruch, the son of Neriah, when asked, explained how he had heard the words of Jeremiah prophesying, saying: 'Out of his mouth he spoke as if reading, and I was writing' (Jer. 36:18). For he who speaks while reading directs himself to one thing, but makes his word about another, because he says what he sees.
The prophets of God, therefore, because they see His words in the heart rather than hear them, speak as though reading. 3. How He is wont to speak through angels: sometimes by words, sometimes by deeds, sometimes by words and deeds at once, sometimes by images shown to the eyes of the heart or of the body. When the Lord indicates His will through an angel, sometimes He demonstrates it by words, sometimes by deeds, sometimes by words and deeds together, sometimes by images shown to the eyes of the heart, sometimes by images taken for a time from the air even before the bodily eyes, sometimes by heavenly substances, sometimes by earthly ones, sometimes by earthly and heavenly ones at once.
Sometimes indeed God speaks to human hearts even through an angel in such a way that the angel itself is also presented to the gaze of the mind. For God speaks by words through an angel when nothing is shown in an image, but the words of a heavenly utterance are heard, as when, at the Lord's saying, 'Father, glorify your Son, that your Son also may glorify you,' it is at once answered: 'I have glorified it, and I will glorify it again' (John 17:1, 12:28). For neither did God, who without time cries out by the power of inward impulse, in time utter through His own substance that voice which, circumscribed by time, He distinguished through human words; but doubtless, speaking of heavenly things, He formed the words which He willed to be heard by men, by the ministry of a rational creature.
Sometimes God speaks by deeds through angels, when nothing is said in word, but the things that are to come are announced by an image taken from the elements; as Ezekiel, hearing nothing of words, saw the likeness of amber in the midst of the fire, so that, while he gazed on the likeness alone, he might perceive the things that were to come in the last days (Ezek. 1:4). For amber is compounded from the metal of gold and of silver, in which mixture the silver is indeed rendered brighter, yet the splendor of the gold is tempered. What, then, is shown in the amber but the Mediator of God and men? Who, when He composed Himself for us out of the divine and human nature, both rendered the human brighter through the deity, and tempered the divine to our sight through the humanity.
For because by the power of His divinity His humanity shone with so many miracles, the silver grew out of the gold; and because through the flesh God could be known, and because through the flesh He endured so many adversities, the gold was as it were tempered out of the silver. This is well shown also in the midst of the fire, because the flame of the judgment that follows accompanies the mystery of His incarnation. For it is written: 'The Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son' (John 5:22). 6. Sometimes God speaks through angels by words and deeds together, when by certain motions He intimates that which He narrates by discourse. For neither could Adam, after his fault, hear the Lord in the substance of the divinity, but he heard the words of rebuke through an angel, of whom it is written:
CumaudissetvocemDominiDeibdeambulantiainparadisoadaurampostmeridiem, absconditseinterlignaparadisi (Genes. III, 8). QuidestenimquodpostpeccatumhominisinparadisoDominusjamnonstat, seddeambulat, nisiquodirruenteculpaaseacordishominismotumdemonstrat?Quidestquodadaurampostmeridiem, nisi 895 quodluxferventiorveritatisabscesserat, etpeccatricemanimamculpaesuaefrigoraconstringebant? IncrepavitergoAdamdeambulaos, utcaecismentibusnequitiamsuamnonsolumsermonibus, sedetiamrebusaperiret, quatenuspeccalorhomoetperverbaquodfecerataudiret.
'When he had heard the voice of the Lord God walking in paradise in the breeze after midday, he hid himself among the trees of paradise' (Gen. 3:8). For what is it that, after man's sin, the Lord in paradise no longer stands, but walks, except that by the inrushing of guilt He demonstrates a movement away from the heart of man? What is it that He comes 'in the breeze after midday,' except that the more fervent light of truth had departed, and the chills of his guilt were constraining the sinful soul? He therefore rebuked Adam by walking, that to blind minds He might disclose their wickedness not only by discourses but also by deeds, so that sinful man might both hear through words what he had done,
and, through the walking, having lost the state of eternity, might discern the inconstancy of his own mutability; and, through the breeze, the fervor of charity being expelled, might notice his own torpor; and, through the declining of the sun, might recognize that he was drawing near to darkness. 7. Sometimes God speaks through angels by images shown to the eyes of the heart, as Jacob, while sleeping, saw a ladder resting against heaven (Gen. 28:12); as Peter, caught up in ecstasy, beheld a linen sheet full of reptiles and quadrupeds (Acts 10:11), who, unless he beheld these things with incorporeal eyes, would not have been in ecstasy; as to Paul in a vision of the night a man of Macedonia appeared (Acts 16:9), who begged him to cross over into Macedonia.
Sometimes God speaks through angels by images taken for a time from the air even before the bodily eyes, as Abraham was able not only to see three men, but also to receive them into his earthly dwelling, and not only to receive them, but even to supply food to their use (Gen. 18:1ff.). For unless the angels, announcing to us certain inner things, took bodies for a time from the air, they would certainly not appear to our outward gaze; nor would they take food with Abraham, unless for our sake they bore something solid from the heavenly element.
Nor is it any wonder that there those same beings who were received are called now angels, now the Lord; because by the name of angels are expressed those who ministered outwardly, and by the appellation of the Lord is shown Him who inwardly presided over them, so that through the one the command of the presiding one, and through the other the office of the ministering ones, might shine forth. 8. Various other ways in which God speaks to men. Sometimes God speaks through angels by heavenly substances, as, when the Lord was baptized, it is written that a voice sounded from the cloud, saying: 'This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased' (Matt. 3:17). Sometimes God speaks through angels by earthly substances, as when He reproved Balaam and formed human words in the mouth of the she-ass (Num.
22:28). Sometimes God speaks through angels by earthly and heavenly substances at once, as when to Moses on the mountain, when He uttered the words of His command, He joined fire and the bush, and united the one above, the other below (Exod. 3:2). Yet this is done only then, when by the very conjunction something is signified. For addressing Moses through the kindled bush, what else did He show but that he would become the leader of that people who would both receive the flame of the law, and yet would in no way avoid the thorn of sin? Or that he would go forth also with that people who, in the fire of the Deity, would take on the sins of our flesh as it were the thorns of the bush, and would preserve the unconsumed substance of our humanity even in the very flame of the divinity? 9.
Prophets sometimes inspired through angels. But sometimes God, even through angels present to human hearts by their secret presence, infuses the power of His inspiration. Whence Zechariah also says: 'And the angel who spoke in me said to me' (Zech. 1:14). While he says that the angel spoke to him, yet in him, he clearly shows that He who made words to him was not outside in a bodily form. Whence also a little after he added: 'And behold, the angel who spoke in me went forth' (ibid. 2:3). For often they do not appear outwardly, but as they go, the angelic spirits make known the will of God to the senses of the prophets, and lift them up to sublime things, and show them things that are to be in the future in their original causes.
For the human heart, weighed down by the very burden of corruptible flesh, sustaining this its own corpulence as it were a barrier, does not penetrate inner things, and lies heavy without, because it has not within a hand to lift it. Whence it comes to pass, as has been said, that to the senses of the prophets the very subtlety of angelic power appears as it is, and their mind is lifted up by whatever subtle spirit it languishes for; and it no longer lies sluggish and torpid in the depths, but, filled with inmost loves, ascends to the heights, and thence, as from a certain summit of things, sees the things that are to come beneath it.
But lest anyone should think that by the angel designated in the aforesaid words of Zechariah is meant the Lord—whether the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Spirit—if he considers the text of Sacred Scripture, he quickly corrects what he supposes; for Scripture never calls the Father an angel, never the Holy Spirit, and calls the Son an angel only through the preaching of His incarnation. Whence also in these same words of Zechariah it is openly shown that in him a true angel, that is, a creature, was speaking, when it is said: 'And behold, the angel who spoke in me went forth' (Zech. 2:3). And at once it is subjoined: 'And another angel went forth to meet him, and said to him: Run, speak to this young man, saying: Jerusalem shall be inhabited without a wall' (ibid. 2:4).
The angel who is sent, therefore, to whom the words that he ought to say are commanded by an angel, is not God. But because in the sight of the Creator the angelic ministries are distinguished by an ordered arrangement of ranks, so that both, for the common felicity of blessedness, they may rejoice in seeing their Maker together, and yet, according to the disposition of dignity, some may minister to others, an angel sends an angel to the prophet, and instructs and directs him whom it beholds rejoicing together with itself in God, because it surpasses him both by superior knowledge in the power of cognition, and by more excellent grace in the summit of power. 10. How God answered Job. These things, then, have been said in order that it might be demonstrated in what ways God speaks to men.
But when the Lord is said to have answered blessed Job out of the whirlwind, whether He spoke to him through Himself, or through an angel, is doubtful. For the commotions of the air could have been made through an angel, and these words which are subjoined could have been commanded to him through it. And again, an angel could both outwardly shake the air in the whirlwind, and yet inwardly the Lord Himself, through Himself, could sound the force of His judgment to his heart without words, so that it may be believed that the Lord's sayings which follow, He indeed brought forth through words, who, filled with God, heard these things without words. And so it is said: